Walking your dog should be a joyful experience, but what happens when your dog hates wearing a harness? Many pet owners face this dilemma and wonder, “Should I use a dog harness or a collar?”
In this ultimate guide, we’ll explore why some dogs resist harnesses, compare collars and harnesses in detail, and share practical tips to help your dog feel comfortable. By the end, you’ll know which is best for your furry friend and how to make walks stress-free.
Why Some Dogs Don’t Like Harnesses?
There are many reason your dogs don't like harness. If your dog fights, freezes, or runs away when you bring out the harness, it’s not unusual. Dogs dislike harnesses for several reasons:
1️⃣ Unfamiliar Sensation
Harnesses cover more of a dog’s body than collars. For dogs used to the minimal touch of a collar, the wrap-around design can feel strange or even restrictive.
2️⃣ Bad Associations
If your dog first experienced a harness during a scary event (like a vet visit or a loud street walk), they might link it to fear or discomfort.
3️⃣ Poor Fit or Wrong Style
A harness that’s too tight, too loose, or rubs under their armpits can irritate your dog’s skin and make them dread wearing it.
4️⃣ Sensitive Skin or Coat
Some materials, like stiff nylon, can cause chafing on short-haired dogs or mats on long-haired breeds.
5️⃣ Restrictive Feeling
Certain dogs, especially high-energy breeds, dislike anything that limits their full range of motion.
Dog Harness vs Collar: Which Is Better?
Before choosing, it’s important to understand the pros and cons of each.
Feature: Dog Harness, Dog Collar, Pressure Distribution Evenly spreads pressure across the chest. Focuses pressure on neck/trachea. Control Offers more control for strong pullers. Less control with excitable dogs. Safety Prevents choking and injury. Can strain neck if dog pulls hard. Ease of Use: Takes longer to put on. Quick and easy to slip on/off. Ideal for training small breeds and brachycephalic dogs. Calm walkers, ID tags at home.
✅ When to Choose a Harness
A harness is the better choice if:
- Your dog pulls on the leash.
- You have a small or fragile breed (like Chihuahuas or Yorkies).
- Your dog has tracheal or neck issues.
- You’re leash training a puppy.
- You want extra security for car travel.
✅ When a Collar Is Enough
A collar works well if:
- Your dog is leash-trained and doesn’t pull.
- You’re just taking quick potty breaks in safe areas.
- You need a place for ID tags when indoors.
Why Harnesses Are Safer for Pulling Dogs?
Dogs that pull on walks can injure their trachea with a collar. The pressure from a collar compresses the neck, which may lead to
- Tracheal collapse (common in small breeds)
- Neck strains or sprains
- Thyroid gland damage in severe cases
Harnesses distribute the force across the chest and shoulders, reducing the risk of injury.
How to Get Your Dog Used to a Harness?
If your dog hates their harness, don’t give up. With patience and positive reinforcement, most dogs can learn to love it.
1: Make It Positive
- Place the harness on the floor and let your dog sniff it.
- Give treats and praise every time they interact with it calmly.
2: Practice at Home
- Put the harness on for just a few seconds indoors.
- Reward your dog immediately with treats or play.
- Gradually increase the time they wear it each day.
3: Associate with Fun
- Only put the harness on before walks or playtime—not during stressful events.
4: Check the Fit
A poor fit causes discomfort. Adjust the harness so
- You can fit two fingers between the straps and your dog’s body.
- It doesn’t rub their armpits or chest.
What Type of Harness Is Best for Reluctant Dogs?
If your dog hates their current harness, consider switching to a more comfortable style:
Step-In Harness
Easier to put on than over-the-head designs. Great for nervous dogs.
Soft Mesh Harness
Lightweight and breathable—perfect for small breeds or dogs with sensitive skin.
No-Pull Harness
Redirects pulling without choking. Ideal for training.
Dog Harness Vs Collar for Dog That Pull
For dogs that pull hard, dog harness is the clear winner. Choose a no-pull harness with front and back leash attachments to train your dog to walk calmly.
Warning: Avoid choke chains and prong collars—they can cause pain and long-term damage.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Forcing the harness on too quickly.
Using the wrong size or style for your dog’s breed.
Skipping positive reinforcement.
Keeping the harness on 24/7 (it can cause irritation).
FAQs About Dog Harnesses and Collars
Should dogs wear a harness all the time?
No. Only use it during walks or training. Leaving it on can cause skin irritation.
Can a dog wear both a collar and a harness?
Yes. Use the collar for ID tags and the harness for walking.
Is a harness better for puppies?
Yes. Puppies are still learning leash manners, and a harness prevents neck strain.
Final Thoughts: Harness or Collar?
After reveing Dog Harness Vs Collar the finalization is:
If your dog pulls, is small, or has health issues, go for a harness.
If your dog is well-trained and walks calmly, → a collar may be fine.
But if your dog doesn’t like a harness, don’t worry—patience and training can turn it into a positive experience.
Your dog’s comfort and safety come first. Start slow, use plenty of treats, and choose the right gear for your best friend.
